Amy Gumenick is a Swedish-born American actress. She is best known as young Mary Winchester in Supernatural, as the villain Carrie Cutter, also called Cupid, in Arrow, and as Natalee Holloway in Lifetime’s 2009 TV movie. As of November 2026 she is 40, and her most recent listed screen credit is a 2024 guest role in Criminal Minds.
Quick facts
- Full name: Amy Jaclyn Gumenick
- Date of birth: May 17, 1986
- Age: 40 (as of November 2026)
- Birthplace: Hudiksvall, Sweden
- Profession: Actress
- Known for: Supernatural, Arrow, Natalee Holloway, Turn: Washington’s Spies
Amy Gumenick was born on May 17, 1986, in Hudiksvall, Sweden. In 2008 she graduated from the University of California, Santa Barbara, with a BFA in theatre and an emphasis in acting. Her first credited role was in the 2005 short film Sayonara Elviko. Her television debut came in 2008, when she played Lee Ann in an episode of Army Wives.
In 2009 she had guest roles in several major network shows:
- How I Met Your Mother: Amanda, in “Three Days of Snow” (January 19, 2009)
- Grey’s Anatomy: Becca Wells, in “What a Difference a Day Makes”
- Ghost Whisperer: Gwen Collier, in “See No Evil”
- Bones: Paige Sayles, in “The Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood”
The rest of this page covers her background, main roles and career timeline.
Amy Gumenick Profile Facts
- Birth name: Amy Jaclyn Gumenick
- Occupation: Actress
- Date of birth: May 17, 1986
- Place of birth: Hudiksvall, Sweden
- Nationality: Swedish-American (she holds Swedish and US citizenship)
- Education: University of California, Santa Barbara (BFA in theatre, 2008)
- Debut film: Sayonara Elviko (2005, short film)
- Debut TV: Army Wives (2008)
Career Highlights
Her career has been built on television. A run of guest parts in 2008 and 2009 led to recurring roles in genre series.
Supernatural: young Mary Winchester
On Supernatural she played Mary Campbell, the mother of Sam and Dean Winchester, as a young woman. Her flashback episodes aired in 2008 and 2010. Fans of the show still link her name with the role. She has also appeared as herself on a Supernatural podcast series (2023 to 2024).
Natalee Holloway (2009) and its sequel
She played the title role in Natalee Holloway, a Lifetime TV movie that aired on April 19, 2009. Tracy Pollan played Beth Holloway-Twitty and Grant Show also starred. When it aired, the film drew Lifetime’s highest ratings to that date. Gumenick, Pollan and Show all returned for Justice for Natalee Holloway, which aired on Lifetime on May 9, 2011.
Arrow: Carrie Cutter, also called Cupid
The CW’s Arrow cast her in 2014 as Carrie Cutter, an obsessive fan who becomes the villain Cupid. The comic book character was created by Andrew Kreisberg, an Arrow executive producer, and artist David Baron. She was first signed for two episodes, and the character returned on and off until 2019, for seven episodes in all.
Turn: Washington’s Spies and later work
From 2014 to 2017 she played Philomena Cheer in AMC’s Revolutionary War drama Turn: Washington’s Spies. She also played Gilda Darner in NBC’s Grimm. Her latest listed screen credit is Emma Song in the Criminal Minds episode “Piranha” (July 2024).
Career Timeline
| Year | Title | Role |
|---|---|---|
| 2005 | Sayonara Elviko (short film) | Debut film role |
| 2008 | Army Wives | Lee Ann |
| 2008, 2010 | Supernatural | Young Mary Campbell (Winchester) |
| 2009 | How I Met Your Mother | Amanda |
| 2009 | Grey’s Anatomy | Becca Wells |
| 2009 | Ghost Whisperer | Gwen Collier |
| 2009 | Bones | Paige Sayles |
| 2009 | Natalee Holloway (TV movie) | Natalee Holloway |
| 2011 | Justice for Natalee Holloway (TV movie) | Natalee Holloway |
| 2014 to 2017 | Turn: Washington’s Spies | Philomena Cheer |
| 2014 to 2019 | Arrow | Carrie Cutter / Cupid |
| 2024 | Criminal Minds | Emma Song |
FAQ
How old is Amy Gumenick?
Amy Gumenick was born on May 17, 1986, so she is 40 as of November 2026. She turns 41 on May 17, 2027.
Where is Amy Gumenick from?
She was born in Hudiksvall, Sweden, and holds both Swedish and US citizenship. She studied theatre at the University of California, Santa Barbara, and graduated in 2008.
How tall is Amy Gumenick?
No official or reputable source gives her height. Figures on fan and aggregator sites are unverified, so they are not listed here.
Who did Amy Gumenick play in Supernatural and Arrow?
In Supernatural she played the young Mary Campbell, later Mary Winchester, first in the 2008 episode “In the Beginning” and next in the 2010 episode “The Song Remains the Same.” In Arrow she played Carrie Cutter, the villain known as Cupid, in seven episodes from 2014 to 2019.
Is Amy Gumenick married or dating anyone?
She keeps her private life out of the press, and no reputable outlet has confirmed a husband or partner. Claims about her relationships on gossip sites are unconfirmed.
What is Amy Gumenick doing now?
Her most recent listed screen credit is Emma Song in the Criminal Minds episode “Piranha,” from July 2024. She has also appeared as herself on a Supernatural podcast series in 2023 and 2024. No newer project has been announced as of November 2026.
Sources
- Amy Gumenick on Wikipedia
- Amy Gumenick on IMDb
- Amy Gumenick on TVmaze
- Natalee Holloway (film) on Wikipedia)
- TheWrap: ‘Arrow’ Casts ‘Supernatural’ Alum Amy Gumenick
- BroadwayWorld: Arrow Adds Supernatural Alum to Season 3
